Posted by Akhoya on April 23rd, 2010 at 3:22 pm in Politics
Alaska
It seems the French are a bit fixated on the concept of identity. Their current events are always filled with issues of how (or whether) immigrants are integrating into society, whether the government will ban the wearing of burqas in public, etc., and the question "What does it mean to be French?"
A few months ago, Mr le President Nicholas Sarkozy even created had a nation-wide series of townhall meetings on France's national identity. They turned out to be a total flop - but all the same, I guess all I'm trying to say is...
What do you think makes the American identity? Is there such a thing? Is there an Alaskan identity? Is this question important whatsoever?
Poll (Click to toggle)
Do you consider yourself more Alaskan or American?
The American identity to the world is much different then the American identity within our borders. Growing up we are taught that this is the land of opportunity, you can do anything, and everyone is accepted, the land of the free, home of the brave blah blah blah. It is true, that it is mostly possible to achieve anything you put your mind to , but statistically for a lot of people, it is an unrealistic notion. Low-income neighborhoods all across the nation are terribly limited through socio-economic boundaries. Although we let anyone in our borders (or we used to anyway), there is still rampant racism, and gay marriage has hardly been able to gain a foothold in a lot of states, drug users are thought of as lower life-forms, and with the recent War on Terror, anyone from the middle east is immediately stared at and suspect of being a terrorist. The only true American Identity any of us can unarguably unite under is that we are consumers, ruled by capitalists, mostly oblivious to consequences of our consumption. I would like to think of myself as Alaskan, but the truth is, the "Alaskans" identity is one that I wouldn't want to associate myself with under any circumstances. (Rape the land, there's always enough, Throw your trash in the backyard, Government can't tell me what to do, own a gun, drink beer.) I am Alaskan, though, and more so, I am American, and that I think proves that putting an identity on an entire group of people is just as lame and pointless as categorizing people in your highschool by who they hang out with.
With all civilian casualties put into account, the environmental catastrophes that our corporations sponsor, the coups that our CIA have executed, and our government's successive failure to provide progressive leadership in the climate change crisis, I can only hope that at best people around the world see the American Identity as being Innocent, brainwashed misinformed tools who do not truly understand the destruction we salute.
What's more important, is that I identify myself as a member of this Earth, not just a member, but THE top predator and as an American, the most powerful top predator the earth has ever seen. To quote spiderman -
I tend to identify more as an Alaskan rather than an American. As you can plainly see.
France's position is interesting...for hundreds of years their little nation (smaller than the size of Texas) has fought through plenty of cultural impositions from nasty foreigners. So aside from what is it, parts of Belgium and Canada, France is the only heart of their culture. inb4 PHRANCH MILLUTARI SUXXXXXX.
As for an American identity...well the ideals attributed to that nebulous thing of American identity...I would hope are at least the concepts of work-your-way and accept new people and ideas...indeed thats the only thing thats kept us in our seat of global superpower methinks.
France has been the largest nation in Europe in both population and territory in the past, and it continues to be large by those standards. Of course, France has not always had a single identity by any means - it wasn't even more or less linguistically unified until after the Revolution.
I would say the American identity comes down to one thing: appreciating the benefits of being an American. Otherwise, you can have any culture or background and still be an American. And yes, I agree that's what has made this nation powerful. What if, post-Civil War when we started getting boatloads of immigrants, the US kept more people out and decided to stay as Anglo-Saxon as possible? Right now this place would be weaksauce.
France was Europe's largest at least as long as the USSR existed (as long as you exclude the USSR as a European country, of course). Since 1991 Ukraine's had the top spot. (And then of course you have Napoleon and who knows what other points in history.)
VexingStockBroker
04/25/10|12:32 pm
With all civilian casualties put into account, the environmental catastrophes that our corporations sponsor, the coups that our CIA have executed, and our government's successive failure to provide progressive leadership in the climate change crisis, I can only hope that at best people around the world see the American Identity as being Innocent, brainwashed misinformed tools who do not truly understand the destruction we salute.
What's more important, is that I identify myself as a member of this Earth, not just a member, but THE top predator and as an American, the most powerful top predator the earth has ever seen. To quote spiderman -
"With Great power comes great responsibility."
Clamroyale
04/23/10|4:48 pm
I tend to identify more as an Alaskan rather than an American. As you can plainly see.
France's position is interesting...for hundreds of years their little nation (smaller than the size of Texas) has fought through plenty of cultural impositions from nasty foreigners. So aside from what is it, parts of Belgium and Canada, France is the only heart of their culture. inb4 PHRANCH MILLUTARI SUXXXXXX.
As for an American identity...well the ideals attributed to that nebulous thing of American identity...I would hope are at least the concepts of work-your-way and accept new people and ideas...indeed thats the only thing thats kept us in our seat of global superpower methinks.
Akhoya
04/23/10|5:05 pm
I would say the American identity comes down to one thing: appreciating the benefits of being an American. Otherwise, you can have any culture or background and still be an American. And yes, I agree that's what has made this nation powerful. What if, post-Civil War when we started getting boatloads of immigrants, the US kept more people out and decided to stay as Anglo-Saxon as possible? Right now this place would be weaksauce.
Clamroyale
04/24/10|1:56 am
Clamroyale
04/24/10|2:01 am
But really? Largest in territory? When? Am I overlooking the obvious with Napoleon's escapades? Inform me plz.
Akhoya
04/24/10|9:46 am
AgentOrange
04/23/10|3:27 pm
Catalyst
04/23/10|4:15 pm
wait.
The Crimson Nutcase
04/23/10|3:25 pm
italic: <i>text</i>
underline: <u>text</u>
color: <color=blue>text</color>
URL: <url=http://google.com>Google</url>
< and > can be replaced with [ and ]